“Connecting The Canon To Current Young Adult Literature” (Due Wednesday, 30th)
- Antonio Hamilton
- Jan 1, 2019
- 1 min read
Comment 2 questions and answer one of your classmate's questions.
top of page
ENC 2135: Research, Genre, & Context
QQC Posts Due by 10pm the night before we are scheduled to discuss them in class.
Search
15 Comments
bottom of page
Q1.) The article mentions that traditional pieces of literature taught in schools (for example, "To Kill a Mockingbird") have already been analyzed so extensively, potentially causing them to limit opportunity for critical thinking among students. Is this true?
Q2.) "The rationale for using YAL might include its Goodreads rating and various awards to show its merit." Should educators be choosing books to teach their students solely on popularity and appraisal? Why or why not?
In response to Spencer, I personally think it is ridiculous for parents and school boards alike to think YAL has the capability of "ruining a young child's mind". If adults are not yet aware that tenth graders use profanity in their daily lives and are already…
Q1: From personal experience of reading both Literary Canon books and YAL books, do you think it was a good match or should not be taught together in lessons?
Q2: The author wrote " ...ready-made and easily available literary analyses denied students opportunities for critical thinking". Is this agreeable or does YAL books give another way of critical thinking in lessons?
In response to Daniel , I do believe that it is beneficial to read both kinds of books because there are lessons and other things that you can learn from in both types of books that could be helpful for inside school and out.
Q1 what do you think is the minimum age for YAL books
Q2 do you think YAL books can ruin a young mind
A1 in response to jakes question yes it was easier to understand the article with bold titles
q1. Do you think YAL or Literary Canon novels are more beneficial in classrooms?
q2. What are some Young Adult Literary novels that could be classified as Literary Canon?
In response to Leemor, Yes I think that young adult novels could replace classics. Students will be able to relate to the book more and make it easier to understand.
Q1) Do you think it’s a good idea to pair popular young adult literature and traditional canon?
Q2) Do you believe that any of the young adult literature will ever make it as traditional canon?
In response to Amanda’s first question, I do think that the majority of the same lessons can come from both YAL and literary canon, however, I still think canon literature is important and should be taught in the classroom.